Who can open a dispute, and when
- Clients can dispute a delivery while it is in the review window (7 days unless your contract says otherwise), including a paid weekly invoice on an hourly contract (to contest the hours) or a month that has ended on a retainer. A client can also open a dispute when funded fixed-price work is past its due date or the contract deadline and has not been delivered.
- Editors and designers can open a dispute about any money that is held in escrow for their work, funded or delivered, for example when a client neither approves nor answers.
- One dispute at a time per contract, and each dispute is about one milestone, invoice or month.
- A dispute cannot be opened on a payment the card holder is already disputing with their bank (a chargeback). In that case the bank decides, not SharkCollab.
What happens when a dispute opens
The contract is frozen while the dispute is open, so nothing moves before a decision:
- No money is released, by approval or automatically, and nothing new is funded.
- The review window is paused. If the dispute is withdrawn, it resumes with the time that was left (at least one day).
- Editing in the manuscript workspace, deliveries, revision requests, time logging and contract changes are on hold. A pending deadline-extension request and any open contract change are withdrawn.
Deadlines
- The other side has 3 days to respond. If they do not, the dispute goes to the SharkCollab team anyway.
- The team decides within 10 days of the dispute opening, and always at least 5 days before the money's payment-holding limit runs out. Payments can only be held for a limited time (it depends on the provider's country), so a dispute is never allowed to run past that limit.
Evidence
Both sides can add statements and files while the dispute is open, and the SharkCollab team can message you both. To decide, the team may read the contract chat, open files and look at manuscript versions. Every such read is recorded on the contract timeline, which both of you can see. Staff do not browse chats or manuscripts at any other time.
The decision
There are three possible outcomes for the money in the dispute:
- Release in full to the editor or designer.
- Partial refund to the client, and the rest released.
- Full refund to the client.
The team can also end the contract (anything else still held is refunded and unfunded milestones are cancelled), and may record a violation against either side when the agreed terms were breached. The reasoning is sent to you both. A full refund on a fixed-price contract always ends it. If any money was released, the contract counts as completed and reviews open as usual; if everything was refunded, there are no reviews.
Credit you used toward a payment is returned in the same proportion as the money that is refunded.
Withdrawing
Whoever opened the dispute can withdraw it before a decision. The contract then carries on where it was.
Card chargebacks are different
A chargeback is raised with the card holder's bank, not with SharkCollab. We can give the bank the contract terms and the history of the work as evidence, and the bank decides. If the bank returns money to the card holder while it is still held in escrow, the editor or designer is not paid for that part.